Heads-Up: Upswing Resilient Investor Guide - Stock Liquidity

 


Let’s dive in liquidity of stocks [1,52-54] and related BI indicators such as the Average Daily Traded Volume (ADTV) and Share Turnover (SHT),  Depth of Market (DOM), Bid-Ask Spread (BAS) and optional Variance Ratio (VR).  Liquidity refers to the efficiency or ease with which an asset can be converted into ready cash without affecting its market price. The easier it is to buy and sell an asset, the more liquid it is. Liquidity applies to any financial market, from stocks to precious metals, but some are more liquid than others. The most liquid asset of all is cash itself. Tangible assets, such as real estate, fine art, and collectibles, are all relatively illiquid. Most securities, such as stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, bonds and commodities are liquid assets. The most liquid market in the world is forex [53].  

Generally, stocks of companies with the largest MC are quite liquid (Green). If a stock cannot be sold easily without a considerable loss, it is considered illiquid (Red). Such stocks are more high-risk to investors as it might be harder to find a buyer unlike stocks that are traded frequently. Securities that are traded over-the-counter (OTC) such as certain complex derivatives are often quite illiquid [1].

Liquidity risk is the risk that investors won’t find a market for their securities, which may prevent them from buying or selling when they want. This is sometimes the case with complicated investment products and products that charge a penalty for early withdrawal or liquidation such as a  certificate of deposit (CD) [55].

But how to measure liquidity in the market? Fortunately, there are a few indicators that can be used to assess how liquid a market is: trading volume, BAS, turnover ratios, etc. [53].

Accounting liquidity is measured with specific ratios [1,56]: Current Ratio (CUR), Quick Ratio (QR), Acid-Test Ratio (ATR) and Cash Ratio (CAR).

What is Average Daily Trading Volume (ADTV)? ADTV is the average number of shares traded within a day in a given stock. Daily volume is how many shares are traded each day, but this can be averaged over a number of days to find the average daily volume. ADTV is generally compared to either the daily volume or another average calculated over a different time frame, to find how much volume is changing. There are two reasons to pay attention to ADTV: (i) to make sure a stock is liquid enough to get in and out of it quickly and (ii) to make sure the current supply and demand of stock traders was on your side. ADTV is also used by the SEC to ensure companies don’t buy back more shares in one day than the market can handle [55]. The ADTV formula is

ADTV(n days) = (Total Volume Traded During n Days)/n,

where n is the number of days you want to calculate the average daily volume for (e.g., to get the 30-day average trading volume, n=30)[58]. You can calculate the total volume of a trading day by just tallying up the number of times shares changed hands that day. Say, for instance, that Trader 1 buys 700 stock, Trader 2 sells 1000 stock, and trader 3 buys 2000 stock. Then the total volume for that trading sequences would be 700 + 1000 + 2000 = 3700. So say for example that the total volume for a particular company over a 30-day period was 750 million. The ADTV would be 750 million/30 days = 25 million.

TIPS [1]:

(1) You would prefer higher ADTV compared to low ADTV, because with high volume it is easier to get into and out positions. Low volume assets have fewer buyers and sellers, and therefore it may be harder to enter or exit at a desired price.

(2) Monitor ADTV regularly to make sure that the asset still falls within the volume parameters you desire for your trading.

(3) Significant changes in ADTV may signal that something has changed within the asset, and that some further action may be required (Amber).

(4) These are the most liquid market to remember – forex, stocks and commodities.

(5) If you are only planning to buy 100 shares of a stock, the ADTV is pretty much a non-issue because it will be easy to exit such a small position–even in a thinly traded stock. So size does matter (at least when it comes to stocks).

If you notice that ADTV for a particular security is increasing, then that could mean the security has higher liquidity as more buyers and sellers are in the market for it.  Conversely, if ADTV is falling, then that could mean investors are becoming more hesitant to trade in that stock. In general, if a security has a high ADTV it means it is more competitive, has narrower price spreads, and that it is less volatile to rapid changes.

What should be the minimum ADTV requirement for the stocks and ETFs you trade? Although there are free financial websites that provide you with the ADTV, the fastest and best way to gauge the liquidity of a stock is by plotting the data on a stock chart of a quality trading platform [59]. As a general rule of thumb, an ADTV of 20 million or greater provides pretty good liquidity for most traders. By knowing the Average Dollar Volume of a stock, you can lower your minimum ADTV requirement if the stock is trading at a higher price.

Further, Average Dollar Volume (ADV) is a metric that is calculated by multiplying the share price of a stock times its ADTV

ADV = ADTV * Share Price

For example, a $25 stock with an ADTV of 800,000 shares has an ADV=20 million ($25 x 800,000). If a $100 stock has an ADTV of just 200,000 shares, it would be the same ADV=20 million ($100 x 200,000). It appears that both the $25 and $100 stocks to have equal liquidity. Thus, ADV is a more important measure than ADTV. If you trade a rather large account, then consider an AVD > 80 million to ensure plenty of liquidity.


 





Comments

  1. Let’s consider the Bid-Ask Spread (BAS) as the de facto measure of market liquidity [1]. It is typically the difference between ask (offer/sell) price and bid (purchase/buy) price of a stock. Ask price is the value point at which the seller is ready to sell and bid price is the point at which a buyer is ready to buy. When the two value points match in a marketplace, i.e. when a buyer and a seller agree to the prices being offered by each other, a trade takes place. These prices are determined by two market forces -- demand and supply, and the gap between these two forces defines the spread between buy-sell prices. The larger the gap, the greater the spread! BAS can be expressed in absolute as well as percentage terms. When the market is highly liquid, BAS values can be very small, but when the market is illiquid or less liquid, they can be large. To calculate the bid-ask spread percentage, simply take the bid-ask spread and divide it by the sale price. For instance, a $100 stock with a spread of a penny will have a spread percentage of $0.01 / $100 = 0.01%, while a $10 stock with a spread of a dime will have a spread percentage of $0.10 / $10 = 1%. The BAS formula is
    BAS = Ask Price – Bid Price
    If the bid price for a stock is $19 and the ask price for the same stock is $20, then the BAS for the stock is $1. The BAS can also be calculated as a percentage of the ask price, i.e.
    BAS(%)=(1 – Bid Price/Ask Price)*100%
    The BAS matters because market dealers make a profit on BAS. Their job is to buy stocks at the bid price and sell at the ask price. Dealer profit is one reason illiquid or lightly traded stocks tend to have larger spreads than frequently traded stocks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 1.Variance Ratio (VR)
    The Lo-Mackinlay VR test of a random walk is a test used to determine wheather stocks follow a random walk. If stocks exhibit correlation (i.e. non-random walk), then past prices can help in predicting future prices, which would violate the weak form of the efficient market hypothesis [63]. These stocks would be particularly suitable for state-of-the-art AI stock predictors using Amazon Forecast API - a fully managed AWS service that uses statistical and machine learning algorithms to deliver highly accurate time-series forecasts. It is a lot of work to perform the VR test in Excel. Instead, either AWS API’s or statistical software packages (R, Python, MathWorks, etc.) can be used to test the above hypothesis. If stock prices are indeed random walks, then VR=1. Otherwise, VR is either low or high, suggesting negative or positive autocorrelation in the data. Such autocorrelation would imply profitable forecasts based on past prices.

    ReplyDelete
  3. 2.Turnover Ratio (TR)
    The asset TR measures the value of a company's revenue relative to the value of its assets [1]. The TR formulas is
    TR=(Net Sales)/(Average Total Assets).
    Here, net sales equals gross sales minus any sales tax or VAT, sales returns and trade discounts. Average total assets value is calculated by adding the beginning and ending balance of total assets and dividing the sum by 2. The asset turnover ratio is time-dependent in that a ratio for one month would be 1/12th of the ratio for a whole year.
    The higher the TR, the more efficient a company is at generating revenue from its assets. Conversely, if a company has a low TR, it indicates it is not efficiently using its assets to generate sales. If TR(A) of a company A is above the industry average TR(M) (TR(A)>TR(M)), we can conclude that the company has used its assets more effectively in generating revenue.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Key Takeaways
    The ultimate goal of all investors is the ratio min(Risk/Return)=max(Return/Risk)
    The Traffic Light System (TLS) is the all-in-one way to classify the Return/Risk Ratio
    The Risk Severity Matrix is the product Impact * Likelihood of high-risk events
    The TLS assigns the Low, Moderate and High scores to the event Impact/Likelihood
    The Impact versus Likelihood Risk 3x3 Matrix consists of three risk levels L, M and H
    The investment decision score is Green (accept), Amber (research) or Red (reject)
    Portfolio Risk QC metrics/ratios are the standard deviation (STDEV) or volatility of returns, the Alpha/Beta coefficient, the Treynor/Sharpe ratio, Value at Risk (VaR), Conditional VaR (CVaR), R-squared (R2), the EPS Growth Rate, Debt-to-Capital Ratio (DCR), Debt-to-Equity Ratio (DER), Interest Coverage Ratio (ICR), and Degree of Combined Leverage (DCL)
    The Return QC metrics/ratios are ROI, ROE, ROA, EBITDA, Gross/Net/Operating Profit Margin, Market Cap (MC), Total Stock Return (TSR), Earnings per share (EPS), the price-to-earnings ratio (P/E), the price/earnings-to-growth (PEG), Dividend Growth Rate (DGR) and the Dividend Yield (DY), the Discounted Cash Flow model (DCF), Fair Price Per Share, Price-to-Book (P/B) Ratio PBR, Book Value per Share, and ESG rating
    Stock Liquidity Alerts: Average Daily Traded Volume (ADTV), Average Dollar Volume (ADV), Share Turnover (SHT), Depth of Market (DOM), Bid-Ask Spread (BAS), Variance Ratio (VR), Current Ratio (CUR), Quick Ratio (QR), Acid-Test Ratio (ATR) and Cash Ratio (CAR)
    Optimized portfolio setup (best practices): green score to Risk/Return metrics/ratios, successful audits of a company’s financial health, comparing a company against the industry benchmark index and/or a number of competitors within the same industry sector (competitive benchmarking), the best asset to outperform the market, the average Rank for all companies within a specific industry group, and identify the best performing investment within a subset of the broader portfolio

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Max(Reward) Control

Heads-Up: Upswing Resilient Investor Guide - Min(Risk) Control

Appendix B: More Real World Examples